Save
Dig into a cozy dish that blends juicy pulled chicken, a velvety sauce, and a crunchy cornflake crust. Inspired by Paula Deen, this dinner is a hit for all ages. Two kinds of creamy soups team up for a sauce that hugs every bite, and those crispy cornflakes on top are just the right finish to make you want another scoop.
The first time I put this together was at a potluck, and honestly, folks kept coming back for more. Even my picky eater finished every bite and asked for a repeat dinner the next night. Now, it's our go-to Sunday night meal. The smell alone brings everyone to the kitchen way before I call them.
Tasty Ingredients and Top Picks
- Cornflakes: Crunch them up in the bag for easy cleanup and a super crispy finish
- Cheddar cheese: Shred a block of sharp cheddar—melts smoother and tastes richer
- Egg noodles: Wide or medium-sized stand up best when baked
- Sour cream and mayo: Full-fat gives you a silky sauce, but lighter works if that's what you have
- Cream soups: Blend mushroom and chicken soup for a savory, deep-flavored base—choose low-salt if you want
- Chicken: Rotisserie is perfect, with some seasoning that boosts flavor instantly
Simple Step Directions
- Add the Chicken and Noodles:
- Stir in pulled chicken gently
- Lightly toss in the cooked noodles so they don't fall apart
- Make sure every piece is coated well
- Mix Up Your Sauce:
- First, dump both soups, sour cream, and mayo into a bowl
- Whisk smooth, try to get rid of all lumps
- Season with plenty of garlic and onion powders
- This is what makes your dish so good
- Start with Prep:
- Heat your oven to 350°F (175°C)
- Spread butter or oil well inside your baking dish—even in the corners
- No stuck-on mess later and easier to clean up
Save
If you want the casserole to be amazing, take your time with layers. My grandma showed me this trick—don't rush when mixing the noodles into the sauce. Slow down here, or you'll get dry bites. Trust me, it makes a world of difference.
Level Up with Twists
This dish shines because you can change it any way you want. In summer, I toss in some corn and chopped peppers for extra color. Come fall, mushrooms and fresh thyme are my go-to. No matter what, it's always a hit—even though my husband is loyal to the classic version.
Prep It and Forget It
This one is super forgiving. I'll toss everything together in the morning (just not the topping), cover it, and let it chill in the fridge. Top with cornflakes and bake right before eating. The flavors get even better after hanging out a bit.
Easy Temperature Pointers
Let your sour cream and cheese sit out until they're not cold. Then your sauce mixes up smooth, not clumpy. Learned the hard way—cold stuff gives you lumps every time!
Tasty Serving Ideas
You can eat this by itself, but a zesty salad with lemon makes it pop. And when I want to make it fancy, garlic bread always disappears fast on the side.
Save
Honestly, this casserole is way more than dinner—it's a family routine now. I take it to friends who need comfort food or throw it together when time is tight. Every time, that creamy sauce, juicy chicken, and crispy top make everyone happy.
Making this always reminds me why these dishes stick around. They're cozy, easy, and bring everybody together. That's what I call the good stuff—sharing laughs and seconds around the table.
Recipe FAQs
- → Can I swap rotisserie chicken in?
- Absolutely! Shredded rotisserie chicken saves time and works perfectly here.
- → What can replace cornflakes for the crust?
- Crumbled Ritz crackers or panko breadcrumbs are great substitutes for the topping.
- → How can I lighten this up?
- Use low-fat cream soups, Greek yogurt instead of sour cream, and skip the mayo.
- → Can I assemble this before baking?
- Yes, prep it without the topping, cover, and refrigerate. Add the cornflakes just before baking.
- → What sides pair well with this?
- Serve it up with steamed veggies, garlic bread, or a crisp salad for balance.