Save
I can still remember standing on a chair in my mom’s kitchen and helping her mix the dough for these sugar cookies. Every single one comes out super soft and a tiny bit chewy, just the way I like them. There’s a buttery vanilla taste that makes them too good to resist. They work for any celebration or just a random Tuesday sweet tooth moment in my place.
Why These Cookies Stand Out
I tried a ton of versions before nailing down this one. The best part? You can whip up the dough and bake straight away—no waiting in the fridge. These cookies are softer than clouds, have a gentle chew, and the sugary vanilla coating gives them the best sweetness.
Pantry Faves You'll Need
- All-Purpose Flour: Fluff it up and gently scoop it, then smooth the top with a knife. That way, you’ll get the right amount.
- Sugar: Regular white sugar works perfectly for both mixing in and sprinkling on top.
- Butter: Let it get nice and soft by leaving it out for a while. That’s the trick.
- Salt: Just a bit makes all the flavors really shine.
- Baking Powder & Baking Soda: These help give your cookies that puff and soft crumb.
- Vanilla Extract: Go for real vanilla if you can, it brings all the flavor.
- Egg + Egg Yolk: Tossing in an extra yolk makes the cookies rich and tender.
Get Going with Dry Stuff
First, I toss the flour, salt, baking soda, and baking powder into my mixing bowl all together. Giving them a quick whisk makes sure you don’t end up with random clumps or weird tasting spots in the cookies.
Don’t Skip This Part
Plug in your mixer and beat the sugar with the butter until they’re super light and doubled in size. It takes a couple minutes, but trust me, this is where you get that soft, airy bite everyone raves about.
Save
Bringing Dough to Life
This is the fun bit—crack in the egg and the extra yolk, then pour in vanilla. Adding that extra yolk was my biggest win, leaving you with cookies that are unbelievably soft for days.
Finish Mixing
Now carefully add the dry stuff to the wet bowl in a few rounds, stirring just enough after every splash in. As soon as I can’t see flour anymore, I stop. Mixing too long means your cookies end up tough, and nobody wants that.
Make Ball-Shaped Dough
Use a spoon to scoop up some dough and roll it into a little ball with your hands. I always roll them in a bowl of sugar for that extra shimmer and sweet crunch on the outside.
Time to Bake
Line your baking tray with parchment for hassle-free clean up, then set the dough balls down with lots of space, about two inches apart. Pop them into the oven at 350°F for around eight or nine minutes. They should look a bit pale and soft when you take them out.
My Trick for Amazing Cookies
If you’re wondering when to pull them, do it when the middles look soft and underbaked. Let them sit out—they’ll finish cooking as they cool, ending up perfectly chewy and not dry at all.
Save
Let Them Chill
I always wait about five minutes before moving the cookies off the tray. Letting them cool a bit stops them from breaking apart, and then I put them on a rack to firm up all the way.
Make It Your Own
- Extra Sparkle: Whenever a holiday rolls around, I roll the dough in colored sugars for a fun twist.
- Party Time: My family loves them with rainbow sprinkles mixed in for birthdays and get-togethers.
Watch Out For These Mistakes
- Perfect Temperature: Room temp butter is key—you should be able to press an indent, but it shouldn’t look like melted ice cream.
- Gentle Mixing: Don’t get carried away mixing the dough, or you’ll get cookie pucks instead of soft treats.
No Fuss and All Fun
Years of testing came down to getting the ingredient combo just right, so you don’t have to waste time with chilling. That means hot cookies on your plate in no time when you really want one now.
Best Ways to Snack
I like them plain, but they’re just as tasty dunked in morning coffee. My kids can’t get enough dunked in milk, and my partner sneaks one with tea every afternoon.
Save
Keep ‘Em Tasting Great
Pop the cookies into a sealed container and they’ll stay soft all week. If you need to keep them longer, freeze them and they’ll thaw out just fine when you want a treat.
Warm Them Up
Want that straight-from-the-oven vibe? Just microwave one for ten seconds. All the magic of a fresh batch comes right back.
Fun Twists to Try
- Sweet Additions: White chocolate chips are my go-to for making them a little extra for family gatherings.
- Citrus Magic: A bit of lemon zest in the dough lifts the flavor up and keeps the cookies sunny and bright.
You've Got Questions
- Salted or Unsalted Butter? Use either, just remember to use less salt if your butter is salted already.
- Make Ahead Options? Freeze the balls of dough then bake straight from the freezer—just toss on another minute to the timer.
The Soul of Home Baking
I always circle back to these sugar cookies. My family requests them constantly and friends wonder how I get them just right. They’re timeless, simple, and honestly come out spot-on every time.
Summary
Enjoy these chewy golden sugar cookies with ease. They’re quick to bake and don’t need chilling. Perfect for a simple homemade treat.
Recipe FAQs
- → Why include both an egg and egg yolk?
The extra yolk gives the cookies a rich, chewy texture. The fat and protein in yolks make them soft and tender.
- → How can I tell when they’re done?
The tops will be set but look slightly underdone. Let them finish cooking on the warm baking sheet after pulling them out.
- → Is it possible to make the dough in advance?
You don’t have to chill the dough, but you can store it in the fridge for up to 3 days. Bring it to room temp before baking for best results.
- → Why should I spoon and level flour?
This method prevents adding too much flour, which can make the cookies dry and crumbly. Spoon it gently and level with a flat edge.
- → Can these cookies be frozen?
Yep, they freeze great! Seal baked cookies or dough balls in a container, and they’ll stay good for up to 3 months.