Flavorful Mustard Lamb Roast

Last Easter, I cooked up this zesty mustard lamb for dinner and my mother-in-law actually asked me how to make it – which, let's be honest, is basically the cook's version of snagging a gold medal. That layer of herbs and mustard forms the most amazing crunchy crust, locking in the juiciness. Even folks who claim they "aren't into lamb" come back for third helpings.

My brother always says he "can't stand lamb," but last time he polished off three servings. He even tossed out a hint about wanting it again when he comes over next month. Not bad.

Irresistible Mustard Lamb

• Good olive oil: Makes that crust stick perfectly and brings extra richness
• White wine: Splash some in for a killer sauce and really tender lamb
• Soy sauce: Just a bit kicks up the flavor without tipping into stir-fry territory
• Fresh rosemary and thyme: Buy fresh if you can – makes such a huge difference with lamb
• Dijon mustard: Tangy, punchy, and absolutely necessary for the herby topping. Grainy kind is great for texture too
• Boneless lamb leg: Aussie or NZ lamb is generally milder – great for the folks who think they aren’t lamb fans
• Garlic: Go big – lamb can take a lot of bold garlic taste

Save

How I Do It

Getting Ready

Pat your lamb totally dry before you do anything else so the herby-mustard mix goes on easier and tastes way more intense. Letting the lamb hang out and lose its chill (just set it on the counter for a bit) makes such a difference – it actually cooks nice and even that way.

Spreading the Good Stuff

Slap that mustard mix everywhere – don't worry about neatness. I just get in there with my hands and work it into every crack and edge. The messier you get, the better it turns out!

Into the Oven

Kick things off with a really hot oven to build a crust, then drop the heat to finish up gently. I always use a thermometer—timers never get lamb right and it's way too tasty to mess up.

Patience Pays Off

The hardest part? Waiting for it to rest afterward! I always want to carve into it, but if you let it sit loosely under foil for about 15–20 minutes, you get mega-juicy slices. I usually whip up a few side dishes to distract myself during this wait.

I only stumbled on mustard with lamb because I ran out of mint jelly one night. Whipped up some Dijon with fresh herbs, slathered it on, and it honestly blew my old standby out of the water. Now I just put all those goodies right onto the meat instead of the side.

How to Serve It

Goes perfectly with silky mashed potatoes—try them or crispy roasted potatoes for soaking up all that sauce. Any bright green veggie pops on the plate; think roasted asparagus, green beans, or Brussels sprouts. And a glass (okay, maybe two) of good cabernet or syrah? Can’t beat it.

Switch It Up

Mix a spoonful of honey into your mustard for sweet vibes. Want something different? Try oregano or a bit of mint with the herbs. Like a kick? Add grated horseradish to your mustard layer. Lemon zest wakes up all the flavors if you want it fresher.

Easy Storing

Leftover slices go right into sandwiches the next day. Pile up thin lamb pieces, add peppery arugula, and slather on some of your extra mustard mix. Reheating? Go slow and low – 300°F under foil with a splash of broth keeps it tender, not tough.

Save

Cook’s Best Tips

• Have your butcher butterfly the lamb for steady, even cooking
• Crave bigger flavor? Mix up the mustard coating in advance and let it chill in the fridge overnight
• Snag an instant-read thermometer for doneness – seriously takes the guesswork out

I used to get nervous cooking big hunks of meat—lamb especially felt tricky and fancy. Turns out, the easy stuff usually blows people away. The mustard and herbs do all the hard work on flavor. You get to hang out with a glass of wine and still crush it when dinner’s served. This is my low-stress wow-factor dinner now, no sweat.

Recipe FAQs

→ What's the best way to check for medium-rare lamb doneness?

Insert a meat thermometer to see if the lamb reaches 135°F, then let it sit for 20–30 minutes after removing from the heat.

→ Can I prepare parts of this dish in advance?

Whip up the mustard mix a day earlier, but apply and roast the lamb fresh on your serving day for the best taste.

→ What dishes go well with this lamb entrée?

Try pairing it with mashed potatoes, seasonal veggies, crisp greens, or roasted potatoes for a balanced plate.

→ Is it okay to substitute dried for fresh herbs in this?

Fresh herbs smell amazing, but 1 tsp each of dried thyme and rosemary will work if that's what you’ve got.

→ Why does the meat need to rest after cooking?

Resting gives the juices time to settle back into the meat, making each slice moist and flavorful.