Save
Every time this is baking, the whole house just feels extra snug and homelike. I first whipped up this dish during a freezing spell when we all needed something warm and tasty. Fluffy potatoes, juicy chicken, crisp-tender broccoli layered with gooey cheese and crunchy bacon—now this is our go-to for cozy nights in.
Everybody’s Top Pick
I get a kick out of seeing my family perk up as soon as they catch a whiff from the oven. All those creamy potatoes and cheesy chicken piled together—they never stick around long. Even my toughest food critics clean up every bite when this gets served.
Grab These From Your Pantry
- Cheese: Grab 2 cups freshly shredded. We always go sharp cheddar but pick your fave.
- Bacon: Four crispy bacon strips, crumbled on top. My family’s never satisfied with just a little.
- Chicken: About 3 cups chopped. Roasted leftovers work like a charm.
- Broccoli: One medium head, sliced into small bits. Fresh makes it best but frozen's fine.
- My Seasoning Mix: A homemade shake of kosher salt, black pepper, garlic powder, and paprika I’ve dialed in over the years.
- Sour Cream: A whole cup, full fat only for the creamiest potatoes.
- Butter: Four spoonfuls of real butter—don’t skip, it’s worth it.
- Red Potatoes: Three pounds, skins left on for a flavor boost, straight from the neighborhood stand.
Jump Into Cooking
- Chicken Task:
- Chop up your cooked chicken into small bits. Leftover roast chicken brings a lot of flavor, so use what you have.
- Bacon Sizzle:
- Fry up the bacon till it’s nice and crunchy, then crumble. Sneak a piece if you want, nobody’s watching.
- Broccoli Prep:
- Steam the broccoli florets so they brighten up but still keep some bite—not soggy.
- Potato Game:
- Cook your potatoes in salted water for about 15 minutes till they’re soft enough for a fork. Test a chunk or two to be sure.
Get It Silky Smooth
If you want mashed potatoes to come out perfect, blend in the sour cream and butter while they’re still piping hot. Sprinkle in your homemade seasoning mix and give it a taste or two until it hits the sweet spot.
Save
Mix Everything Up
Here’s where it gets good—gently fold in the broccoli, chicken, bacon, and half that shredded cheese. Mixing softly keeps every piece nice and chunky and lets the cheese melt into little oozing pockets.
Layer It In
Grab your usual baking pan and butter it up well. Dump in the mix and spread it out evenly. Smooth the top with a spoon, then sprinkle the last of the cheese right across the surface. Go big here—the more cheese, the better.
Into The Oven
Slide your pan into a hot 350°F oven. Set a timer for 20 minutes, though you’ll want to start checking so the cheese just turns perfectly gooey and golden. The aroma filling your kitchen is next level.
The Tough Bit
As tempting as it is, let the pan rest out of the oven for 5 minutes. This helps all the layers settle and keeps things hold together. Plus, it’s just enough time to round up your hungry crowd.
Plan Ahead
When I’ve got company coming, I prep this the evening before. Just wrap it, pop it in the fridge, and let it sit out about half an hour before it heads into the oven.
Save
Change Things Up
I switch things out now and then—turkey works instead of chicken and different cheeses can be fun to try. Last time I tossed cauliflower in with broccoli and nobody noticed, so feel free to sneak in any extras you like.
Keep The Extras
If you’ve got any left, stash them in the fridge and they’ll be good for three days. I like to reheat them in the oven so that cheesy layer gets crisp again. Just throw some foil over the top to stop it from drying out.
Awesome For Packed Weeks
I usually make this on a Sunday and split it up for a week’s worth of quick lunches. It warms up great and makes any old workday feel special even when you’re just hungry and tired.
Company’s Coming
This is always my sign-up dish for big groups or bringing to a potluck. Travels easy, feeds a crowd, and everybody wants seconds. Just add salad and bread for a simple spread.
The Ultimate Cozy Dish
Honestly, sharing a homemade casserole just brings everyone closer. Ours has made it through birthday parties, cold nights, and every holiday in between. It’s not just dinner—it’s like getting a cozy hug in a pan.
Save
Recipe FAQs
- → Can I prep this a day early?
- Yes, you can assemble it the day before. Just bake longer if it's straight from the fridge.
- → Which potatoes are best?
- Smooth reds work great. You can also use Yukon Golds or Russets for a different texture.
- → Is frozen broccoli okay?
- Yep, it works fine. Just defrost and dry it to avoid too much moisture.
- → What cheese should I pick?
- Sharp cheddar or a Mexican blend is perfect. Any gooey, melt-friendly kind will work.
- → How should I warm leftovers?
- Reheat covered in a 350°F oven or microwave smaller portions until warm.