Creamy Chicken Masala

For years I've been whipping up chicken tikka masala at home, and now my one-pot approach is what I turn to whenever I'm craving Indian food but don't want to blow $50 on delivery. This streamlined version packs all those deep, bold flavors without needing a special oven or a cabinet full of rarely-used spices.

I came up with this method after getting tired of traditional recipes demanding overnight marinating, grilling steps, and separate sauce-making—who can manage all that on a regular weeknight? My version cuts corners cleverly while keeping all the mouthwatering elements that make you crave tikka masala.

Ingredients You'll Want

• Chicken thighs without bones give you juicy, moist meat that stays tender throughout cooking
• Regular yogurt does wonders for softening the chicken even during a short marinade
• Garam masala offers that essential spice combination that forms the dish's foundation
• Kashmiri chili powder (or substitute paprika) creates that gorgeous reddish hue
• Tomato puree forms the tangy base for your silky sauce
• Heavy cream brings that luxurious smoothness that'll make you want to scrape your plate clean

Save

Tasty Preparation Steps

Simple Marinade Technique

To start, I combine chicken chunks with yogurt and spices—garam masala, turmeric, cumin, chili powder, garlic, and ginger. Just 10-15 minutes sitting in this mixture makes a big difference in flavor and texture, though sometimes I'll get it ready before heading to work for dinner later. The yogurt really works wonders here—it softens the meat while helping all those spices stick properly.

Skillet Browning

Rather than using a grill, I brown the spiced chicken in a hot pan until it gets those tasty caramelized edges. Working with small batches matters—filling the pan too much leads to steaming instead of searing, and we want those slightly charred bits that remind you of tandoor cooking. I pull the chicken out when it's almost but not completely done, since it'll finish cooking in the sauce.

Sauce Development

In that same pan (yay for fewer dishes!), I cook onions in butter until they're soft and starting to turn golden. Then I add another dose of garlic and ginger with more warming spices, letting them toast in the hot butter to release their fragrance. Next comes tomato puree, which I let bubble away until it darkens and intensifies. This sauce foundation is where all the real magic happens.

Final Assembly

The crowning touch comes when I pour in heavy cream, which turns the intensely flavored base into something smooth and luxurious. The partially cooked chicken goes back into the pan, including any juice that collected on the plate—that's pure gold you shouldn't waste! Everything simmers gently so the chicken can finish cooking while soaking up all that amazing sauce.

I remember being nervous the first time I made this for my partner, who's super particular about Indian dishes after spending years in London. After his first bite, he went completely quiet, then looked up and said, "This beats that $30 takeout we got last week." That's when I knew I had a winner on my hands.

How To Enjoy It

This tikka masala really needs fluffy basmati rice to soak up that amazing sauce. If you've got extra time, homemade naan takes the meal to another level—there's nothing better than using warm bread to wipe up every last drop. For something lighter, try it with cauliflower rice or a simple cucumber and red onion salad on the side.

Switch Things Around

Want to try something different? Use the same cooking method with paneer cheese instead of chicken for a meat-free option. Tossing in a handful of frozen peas or spinach during the last few minutes adds color and nutrients. For an even richer dish, stir in a spoonful of tomato paste alongside the puree to deepen the flavor profile.

Keeping It Fresh

Like most curry dishes, this one actually tastes even better a day later after all the flavors have mingled together. You can keep leftovers in a sealed container in your fridge for up to three days. Just warm it slowly on the stove with a bit of water to loosen the sauce. It also freezes perfectly for up to three months—great for meal planning or when you need comfort food fast.

Save

Smart Cooking Shortcuts

• Using thigh meat means you won't end up with dry chicken if you cook it a little too long
• Try adding a cinnamon stick while the sauce simmers for an extra flavor dimension
• Putting a spoonful of yogurt on top when serving creates a nice cool contrast to the warm spices

This dish has become my go-to meal when I want to wow dinner guests without stressing myself out. There's something really rewarding about creating such complex flavors in a relatively straightforward way, and nothing beats watching friends go back for more helpings as the ultimate sign of cooking success.

Recipe FAQs

→ Which chicken type works well here?

Boneless, skinless thighs are best since they stay tender as they cook. You can swap for breasts if you'd like, but be sure to not overcook since they dry out faster.

→ Is there a way to lower the spice level?

You bet! Use less or skip the red chili powder. Kashmiri chili mainly boosts color and not spiciness, so keep that if you want. You can also stir in more cream or some sugar to tone things down.

→ How does garam masala differ from curry powder?

Garam masala is a spice mix that skips turmeric, while curry powder is a British creation with turmeric as its base. Use garam masala for that true-to-the-dish flavor.

→ Can I cook this in advance?

Yep! Making it ahead is great, as the flavors get even better after some time. Keep it in the fridge up to 3 days in an airtight container or freeze for up to 3 months. Reheat gently to keep the sauce smooth.

→ What’s a swap for heavy cream?

Evaporated milk is a lighter alternative. For dairy-free, coconut cream or full-fat coconut milk works, but expect a hint of coconut flavor. Plain Greek yogurt thinned with milk is another good option.

→ What sides go well with this dish?

Serve it with warm naan, basmati rice, or roti. You can also include sides like raita (a cucumber yogurt dip), chutney, or a quick salad made with cucumber, tomato, and onion with some lemon juice.